Fence Ownership and Boundary Disputes
In law, every property has a precise legal boundary — an invisible line separating the land owned by one person from that owned by another. Sometimes, the legal boundary coincides with the boundary feature (a fence, for example) and other times this is not the case.
We are sometimes asked to determine or mark on a plan who the owner is and who has responsibility for a legal boundary or a boundary feature. Most often this is because:
- There is a disagreement between neighbours
- A parcel of land, not defined by a boundary feature, is sold
- A boundary feature needs replacing, but the neighbours don’t have any documentation that can help them
Unfortunately, Land Registry doesn’t always hold information that will help establish the precise position of a legal boundary. In such cases, legal presumptions relating to certain types of boundary feature may be helpful.
Fence Ownership and Responsibility
Think of a parade of terraced properties. Generally, each owner will own one fence, except one who will own two fences (usually the owner of an end property). However, no rule dictates which fence (left, right or both) belongs to which property. It is also tempting to assume that ‘the good side of the fence’ should always face away from the fence owner’s land, however, this has traditionally been done as a gesture of goodwill and is not an official rule.
The owner who breaks up the land would normally assign responsibility for the boundaries of the new land parcels that he creates. The conveyance or transfer deed will normally specify the boundaries for which the purchaser is responsible and may also outline the ownership and responsibility of the fences. Sometimes transfer plans show T marks against the boundary, within the land owned by the person responsible for the fence. An H mark (or mirrored T mark) is used for boundaries where the responsibility is shared between two owners. Once you determine the ownership of one fence it is easy to work out the ownership of the remainder.
How do you Determine the Position of the Boundary and the Responsibility over a Fence?
The first thing to do is to check the documents your solicitor provided when you bought the property. If these do not contain any relevant information, see if your neighbours can check their documents. If no useful information can be found, it is recommended to reach an agreement with the neighbours or, worst-case scenario, seek legal advice.
Deeds may contain covenants to maintain a wall or fence, but on their own such covenants do not confer ownership. Where the ownership or responsibility for the maintenance of a boundary cannot be determined, it should be regarded as a party boundary and any alteration/replacement should only be done with the full agreement of the adjoining owners.
When a property is first registered, Land Registry also prepare a Title Plan, based on the Ordnance Survey map and showing the outline of the land in red. Although title plans are drawn to scale, this red border only gives a general indication of the boundary location as established on the General Boundary Rules.
When using a fence to mark a boundary, normal practice is to place the outer faces of the posts alongside the boundary, on the land of the fence’s owner. However, there are a large variety of fence styles and ways of positioning the fence relative to the boundary:
- With wooden close board fences that have panels/boards contained between the posts, the outer faces of the posts are usually placed against the boundary.
- With flat rails attached to the faces of posts and close board fences attached to the faces of flat rails, the outer faces of the boards are usually placed against the boundary.
- With metal/concrete post and wire fences, the outer faces of the posts are usually placed against the boundary and the wires placed through the centre of the posts.
- With round timber post and wire fences, the outer faces of the posts are usually placed against the boundary and the wires stapled to the outer face of the wooden posts.
- If the description of the boundaries in the conveyance deed or on the Land Registry/transfer plan is not clear and you have difficulty determining the boundary’s position on the ground, it is tempting to assume that the position of the fence indicates the position of the boundary. If the fence was in place at the time of the original conveyance or has been in place longer than twelve years, you could conclude that the outer face of the post follows the boundary, although this is not always the case.
Determining a boundary or the responsibility of a fence is not always a straightforward task and there isn’t a scientific approach; sometimes it is a matter of cross-checking old plans, deeds, old photographs and using a bit of common sense. If it is necessary to define the boundary more precisely, Land Registry offers a procedure known as “Determining the Boundary,” for which you will be asked to supply a detailed drawing, most often a topographical survey of the land. For more information, please visit GOV.UK.
* Information contained within this article is informally offered as general guidance and does not constitute legal advice.
You Might Also Like
Be There Without Being There: Videography and Virtual Viewing
Since March 2020 the country has operated in a markedly different way to pre-coronavirus times. The global pandemic has resulted in many changes, but, with the exception of the very first few, fraught months during the original lockdown, we’ve continued to offer our property marketing services throughout, while of course respecting and following government guidelines to the letter to protect both our team and clients. Far from a stagnant market, house sales have boomed as people wake up to the realities of living in crowded cities, or, conversely, being far away from the amenities that they may have previously taken for granted.
Are You Compliant With MEES?
Whether you’re a landlord or perhaps a managing agent, it’s likely that you’ll be aware of the rules around the new Minimum Energy Efficiency Standards (MEES) which are set to come into force on 1st April 2020.
Do Listed Buildings Require An EPC?
In recent years, the British government has embarked on a concerted effort to improve the energy efficiency of our homes. Using grants for insulation and ‘greener’ energy sources, our housing stock is, gradually, being brought up to a higher standard which has benefits to both the environment and our wallets: increased energy efficiency means lower emissions and a smaller carbon footprint, as well as lower energy bills and more comfortable living environments.